I've read this story before many years ago!! I finally decided to come back to AFF and I just had to read your story again!!!! I don't care what everyone says but I love seeing all my favorite Yugioh character's as sex slaves!!! Love reading about yugi being Yami no Marik personal slave!!! Its been so many years for you to not finish this story!!! If you ever decided to come back and finish your story please do!!!! I really want to see Seto/Yugi again!!! I do wanna see Honda and Otogi spend some time with Yugi!!! And Yami too!!
It's also hard to say what your characterization of Yugi is, and how justifiable it is. If he's supposed to be broken, you didn't do a very good job making that transition. He "broke" in the first chapter if that's the case, which would make him incredibly, incredibly weak. And while Yugi is many things -- naive, incompetent, and foolish (though not stupid), for instance -- weakness of will under pain isn't one of his greatest flaws. He isn't perfect, but he's better than THAT. What that implies, then, is that he WANTS to be a sex slave, which I suppose is technically fine, but doesn't seem to draw upon anything specific to Yu-Gi-Oh!. Yugi gives no indication of that kind of desire in the series, so that makes this essentially an original story, not a fanfiction, especially once you throw in how little relation the other characters bear to their true selves. Appearance alone does not a fanfiction make.
Also, what's up with Yugi falling in love with everyone? Has he just gone that crazy? I mean, even if you said his crushes on the other slaves were just desperate gratitude for the (relative) kindness, he was *relieved* to see his master by the beginning of chapter two. Relieved? That his captor, who had brutally raped him and allowed him no release, and then *tied him to the bed overnight* was there? Oh, yes, it was *merely* Yami no Malik -- because it could really have been so much worse! I don't think so.
I could go on and on about how implausible this fic is -- how does Yami no Malik have so much money that he can afford to support a dozen people, at least, in a mansion, with none of them seeming to do any outside work at all? Where is he that this kind of thing is unnoticed, where does he find the people to capture that aren't noticed being gone, and where does he even find the other masters? If it's a PWP, label it as such and let it stand as such. If you're going to toss plot into it, though, make it plausible. This isn't.
I write this review because you have repeatedly mentioned that you have a flamer, and doing that makes an author practically invincible. When someone is being flamed, people naturally support them and encourage them, because that's such an outrageous thing to do. However, that means that honest criticism is often thrown aside, and so that's what this is. That it and use it as you like; my responsibility lies solely in giving you the truth as I see it.
I can't get enough of it, and I can barley wait for more!